Say Yes: Teaching Materials

Say Yes

Download as pdf

Say Yes: Discussion Questions

Say Yes: Writing Assignmentss

Contact AudreyBuy Audrey Couloumbis Titles at Clinton Book ShopReturn to Home Page/Books

Discussion Questions

Created by Phil Bildner, author of “Shoeless Joe and Black Betsy”

If you were meeting Casey and Sylvia for the first time, before the events of this story happened:

What would most people like about Casey? What would most people dislike?

What would most people like about Sylvia? What would most people dislike?

Do you think that Casey’s behavior made life more difficult for Sylvia?

Put some words on the board that might describe Sylvia’s emotions, including isolation, loneliness, fear or scared, desperation, need, sadmess, lost, ashamed, wishful, hopeful, trusting.

In what circumstances do these same words apply to Casey during the story? In what way does she learn from these emotions?

Break into groups of three or four to answer these questions. Everyone should be working with pencil and paper to help them think, but one person might be the reporter when the time comes to read your answers to the class.

a) Name a character from the story and tell in what way they might represent good or evil.

b) What kind of friends would this character be likely to have, whether or not we happened to meet those friends in the story?

c) Think of ten to fifteen questions that you could ask this character, if he were in front of you, to find out more about him. Help each other try to phrase the questions so the character could only give a yes or no answer.

For instance, “what is your name?” is not a workable question. But “Is your name Paulie?” is a workable question.

(instructor: this is much more effective if students are encouraged to ask questions of most of the characters in the story, including Fran, Mrs. Clark, Rocco, Razza, Mrs. Gonzales, Mrs. Wisner, the neighbor with the loud radio, Karen, and Leonard, the nerdy kid who sits between them.)

Did you believe Casey would go through with robbing Mrs. Clark? How did you feel about Casey when she did? Did you feel differently about her at the beginning of the story than after reading the whole story? Did you feel differently about her right after reading the story than you do now when you have had time to think more about the characters and their situations?

What about Sylvia, how did your ideas about her change?

What might either Casey or Sylvia have done that first morning that we saw Casey going off to school to change the way things turned out?

What would it be like to have Casey, Sylvia, or Paulie for a friend? What do you think they learn from each other about being there for each other?

What different behaviors might Casey and Sylvia adopt to show each other how they’ve changed and that they can be trusted?


Created by Phil Bildner, author of “Shoeless Joe and Black Betsy”

1) Choose one of these events from Say Yes:

A woman in upper Manhattan leaves home, abandoning her stepdaughter.

An unknown girl robs Mrs. Clark’s home.

A gypsy tries to take over an apartment in upper Manhattan but is foiled by neighbors. A child is discovered to be living there alone.

A foster parent in upper Manhattan is relieved of his responsibilities after beating a teenager in his care.

2) Write a newspaper article about this singular event.

A news article follows a specific structure. The first paragraph must tell WHO, WHAT, WHEN and WHERE. The second paragraph adds important details. The next paragraphs add details of lesser and lesser importance. Remember, a newspaper reporter is just supposed to report the facts, he or she is not supposed to take sides.

3) Write Casey’s diary.

To do this, you will have to determine what happened on each day of the week for two weeks. Your entries do not have to be any longer than three lines. You don’t have to make up events, and sometimes you will find text in the book that is precisely what Casey would have put in her diary. You can use that. But also try to answer these questions:

What discoveries does Casey make about the things that Sylvia worried about from day to day that Casey now worries about?

How do Casey’s perceptions of the lives being lived around her change over the time that Sylvia is gone?

What do her entries tell you about her and about the other characters? What can you figure out about those characters from what she does not tell you?

4) Choose one character from Say Yes and write a character sketch. Before writing the sketch in paragraph form, answer these questions about the character:

What adjectives can be (or were) used to describe the character’s appearance?

What adjectives will you use to describe the character’s personality in your character sketch?

What would others say about this character and/or how would others react to this character?

How would this character like his or her life to be?

What does (or would) this character think about or how would the character feel about everyday things like school, television, pizza, movies?